Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey 375ML

Skrewball Peanut Butter Whiskey 375ML is a 35% ABV flavored American whiskey infused with natural peanut butter flavors in a 375ml bottle. Widely credited as the brand that pioneered the peanut butter whiskey category, Skrewball earned a Double Gold medal at the 2021 SIP Awards and Best Flavored Whiskey at the 2018 New York World Wine and Spirits Competition.

Quick Facts: ABV: 35% (70 proof)  |  Origin: California, USA  |  Style: Flavored Whiskey  |  Distillery: California Spirits Co

Production & Heritage

Skrewball is produced by California Spirits Co in California, starting with a corn-based American whiskey that is then blended with natural peanut butter flavors, sweeteners, and caramel color. Despite its rich, nutty character, the whiskey contains no actual peanut butter — the distinctive taste comes entirely from natural flavors and aromas carefully integrated into the spirit. Skrewball quickly became the benchmark against which all other peanut butter whiskeys are measured, earning the 2020 Market Watch Leaders Best New Product award as the category exploded in popularity.

Tasting Notes

Aroma: Intense roasted peanut butter dominates the nose, followed by layers of caramel, coffee cream, and toasted vanilla. A shortbread-like sweetness rounds out the bouquet with warm, bakery-shop depth.

Taste: The entry is thick and slightly oily, with immediate vanilla and roasted peanut flavors that several reviewers have compared to a liquid Butterfinger candy bar. The mid-palate reveals honey, caramel, and a whisper of cinnamon, while cracker-like grain notes and a flash of licorice add subtle complexity beneath the sweetness.

Finish: Surprisingly long for a flavored whiskey, with sweet ethanol warmth, nutmeg spice, and lingering honey sweetness. A touch of dry heat balances the residual sugar and keeps it from becoming cloying.

How to Drink Skrewball

Skrewball works well chilled or poured over ice, which tempers the sweetness and highlights the roasted peanut character. It is also a versatile cocktail ingredient: a PB&J Cocktail shaken with raspberry liqueur and cream leans into the nostalgic peanut-butter-and-jelly pairing. A Peanut Butter Old Fashioned substitutes Skrewball for traditional bourbon with chocolate bitters and an orange peel, where the nutty sweetness replaces the need for added sugar. A Peanut Butter Cup Martini combined with chocolate liqueur and cream mirrors the classic candy combination for a rich after-dinner sipper.

Best For

• Introducing a curious friend to the flavored whiskey category
• After-dinner dessert pairings and nightcap cocktails
• Building creative, dessert-style cocktails at home
• Gifting someone who loves peanut butter in all its forms

Frequently Asked Questions

What does Skrewball taste like? Skrewball delivers bold roasted peanut and vanilla flavors with supporting notes of caramel, honey, and a hint of cinnamon. The overall profile is sweet and dessert-like, with multiple reviewers comparing it to a liquid Butterfinger candy bar.

How does Skrewball compare to Sheep Dog Peanut Butter Whiskey? Both are peanut butter–flavored whiskeys, but Skrewball is widely considered the original category creator and tends to have a thicker, sweeter profile. Sheep Dog, produced by Sazerac, is generally described as slightly lighter in body and less intensely sweet.

Is Skrewball good for cocktails? Skrewball's bold peanut butter flavor and natural sweetness make it an excellent cocktail base, particularly in dessert-style drinks like a Peanut Butter Old Fashioned or PB&J Cocktail. Its viscosity also adds body and texture to shaken drinks.

Where is Skrewball made? Skrewball is produced by California Spirits Co in California, USA. The whiskey starts with a corn-based American whiskey that is then blended with natural peanut butter flavors, sweeteners, and caramel color.

What foods pair well with Skrewball? Dark chocolate truffles complement the roasted nut and caramel notes. Banana-based desserts like bananas Foster play off the peanut butter sweetness. Apple slices drizzled with honey create a simple, balanced contrast. Vanilla ice cream or cheesecake work as indulgent dessert pairings. Salty pretzels or crisp bacon provide a savory counterpoint to the sugar.

What sizes does Skrewball come in? Skrewball is available in multiple formats including 50ml miniatures, 375ml half-bottles, standard 750ml bottles, and 1L bottles.

Is Skrewball worth the price? Skrewball positions as an accessible, entry-level flavored whiskey that delivers strong flavor impact for its price tier. Multiple award wins — including a Double Gold at the 2021 SIP Awards — reinforce its standing as the category leader among peanut butter whiskeys.

Why Skrewball?

Skrewball holds a singular position as the brand that effectively created the peanut butter whiskey category, and it remains the name most consumers reach for first. Its accolades — Best Flavored Whiskey at the 2018 New York World Wine and Spirits Competition, Double Gold at the 2021 SIP Awards, and Best New Product at the 2020 Market Watch Leaders awards — are difficult for competitors to match. The 375ml format provides a practical entry point for anyone curious about the style without committing to a full-size bottle. For a flavored whiskey that set the standard and continues to define it, Skrewball is the obvious starting point.